When planning a bathroom remodel, one of the biggest design decisions you’ll face is the tub vs. shower debate. Should you go for a sleek walk-in shower, stick with a classic soaking tub, or install a tub-shower combo for versatility? Each option has its pros and cons, and the best choice depends on your lifestyle, space, and goals for your remodel.
At Day Dreams Remodeling, we specialize in bathroom transformations across Champaign and Miami Counties, helping homeowners create spa-like spaces that reflect their unique preferences. So let’s dive into the key considerations when choosing between a tub and a shower.
Why This Decision Matters in a Bathroom Remodel
Your choice between a tub and a shower impacts more than aesthetics—it affects accessibility, resale value, and daily convenience. Whether you’re upgrading a small bathroom or creating a luxurious primary suite, this decision sets the tone for your entire space.
Tub vs. Shower: Lifestyle Considerations
Benefits of Choosing a Tub
- Perfect for relaxation: Soaking tubs are ideal if you enjoy long, stress-relieving baths at the end of the day.
- Great for families: Households with small children often find bathtubs essential for bath time routines.
- Classic appeal: Freestanding tubs or drop-in tubs can add elegance and charm to traditional or transitional bathrooms.
Benefits of Choosing a Shower
- Faster, more efficient: Showers are perfect for busy households or individuals with fast-paced lifestyles.
- Space-saving: A walk-in shower can open up a small bathroom, making it feel larger and more modern.
- Accessibility: Barrier-free or curbless showers are ideal for aging-in-place or those with mobility concerns.
Space and Layout: What Will Fit Best?
When deciding between a tub vs. shower, take a close look at your bathroom’s layout. Tubs typically require more floor space and a horizontal layout, while showers can be designed to fit into tight or awkward corners.
If you’re remodeling a small bathroom, a custom tile shower with glass doors can make the space feel more open and functional. In larger bathrooms, incorporating both a tub and a walk-in shower can create a luxurious, resort-style atmosphere.
Tub vs. Shower: What About Resale Value?
Many homeowners wonder which option offers better ROI. The answer depends on your market. In family-oriented areas like Troy, Piqua, and Urbana, buyers often look for at least one bathtub in the home. In contrast, if you’re remodeling a master suite or a home for retirement, a walk-in shower might be more appealing.
If you only have one bathroom, keeping a tub is typically the safer choice. But in a home with multiple bathrooms, converting one into a stunning, spa-inspired shower space can be a game-changer.
Can’t Decide? Consider a Tub-Shower Combo
Still torn on the tub vs. shower decision? A tub-shower combo might offer the best of both worlds. This option provides flexibility for households with diverse needs and is especially practical in guest or children’s bathrooms.
Our bathroom remodeling team can help you design a combo setup that’s both stylish and functional, using high-quality materials and thoughtful layouts that make the most of your space.
Custom Design Tailored to You
No matter which direction you go, Day Dreams Remodeling is here to make your vision a reality. We believe that every remodeling project should reflect the personality and lifestyle of the homeowner. That’s why we take the time to listen, collaborate, and offer expert guidance throughout your bathroom renovation.
From elegant freestanding tubs to curbless showers with built-in niches and benches, we handle every detail—from design to installation—with professionalism and care. We serve clients across Champaign and Miami counties, including Saint Paris, Tipp City, and beyond.
Ready to Start Your Bathroom Remodel?
Still weighing the tub vs. shower debate? Let’s talk. Contact Day Dreams Remodeling today, and we’ll help you make the right choice for your home, your style, and your needs. Whether you’re updating a small bathroom or planning a full remodel, our team is here to guide you every step of the way.
